These 13 reptilian species have been observed at the refuge:

• Common Musk Turtle
• Painted Turtle
• Snapping Turtle
• Spotted Turtle
• Wood Turtle
• Five-lined Skink
• Black Rat Snake
• Northern Water Snake
• Black Racer
• Eastern Garter Snake
• Eastern Hognose Snake
• Timber Rattlesnake
• Northern Copperhead

These 14 species of amphibians have been observed at the refuge:

• Mountain Dusky Salamander
• Northern Red Salamander
• Two-lined Salamander
• Northern Dusky Salamander
• Long-tailed Salamander
• Four-toed Salamander
• Red-spotted Newt
• American Toad
• Spring Peeper
• Wood Frog
• American Bullfrog
• Green Frog
• Southern Leopard Frog
• Pickerel Frog